Argos
2-Way 5" Ribbon Bookshelf Speaker Design
2-Way 5" Ribbon Bookshelf Speaker Design
The Argos design is a compact 5" two way bookshelf using the Faital Pro 5FE120 and the Beston RT002A ribbon tweeter. This small bookshelf speaker is capable of more output then its size would suggest and exhibits excellent dispersion characteristics with a good directivity match at the crossover resulting in a wide sound stage and solid imaging. An MTM design is also available on this page below the MT design.
I had been itching to try a ribbon design for a while and decided to go ahead and start with a simple two way bookshelf design. The only real goal was was decent price/performance ratio as I like to stay with more value oriented drivers so that the final design is accessible to those who are on a budget. The Beston RT002A caught my eye for it's ability to be crossed fairly low for a ribbon at 2500Hz. I also liked the implementation on a shallow waveguide which I suspected would give much better control of horizontal directivity then flat surface mounted ribbons.
I knew I wanted to stay in the 5 - 5.25" range for the woofer in order to prevent too much beaming at the crossover. I've had my eye on on the Faital Pro 5FE120 for a number of years as it checks nearly all the boxes, very good sensitivity for a 5" woofer, decent xmax, high power handling, nice flat frequency response that is free of major cone breakup and has low inductance with a shorting ring in the motor as well. Bass extension isn't the best but that's expected given the above average sensitivity and ability to be used in a compact cabinet.
The result, a speaker very impressive for it's size if i do say so myself. The high power handling and decent amount of xmax on the 5FE120 means you will be hard pressed to find it's limits on regular AVR power when crossed to a subwoofer. I find the woofer handles itself very well when pushed hard, I noticed no modulation of the midrange even under very bass heavy content being pushed to and perhaps a little beyond xmax. These won't wow anyone with their bass extension as it falls off hard below 60hz but it is enough to provide decent kick in smaller rooms with most music when used without a subwoofer. That said a subwoofer is recommended if you want full range extension.
The RT002A doesn't have the best distortion performance I have seen from a tweeter, most ribbons don't measure the well when it comes to harmonic distortion but I don't find the sound too objectionable. Most of the harmonics are pushed up above the vocal range which gives the highs a slight sense of false detail, again I don't find it causes any listening fatigue the same way distortion that lands in in the vocal range does. Dynamics and transparency however are great and it seems to give a quicker attack then many cheap domes do which tend to get nasally and compress when pushed hard loosing their detail and separation.
I found the sound stage to be excellent, the very wide and even off axis response does wonders there, imaging good as well. Overall I'd consider these to definitely be a step above my Nexus TM design in terms of output capability, dynamics and clarity while maintaining roughly the same footprint and cabinet size.
Cabinet Design:
The enclosure is 6.5" wide x 10.5" high x 8.5" deep. I used a 3/4" thick baffle and 1/2" panels for the rest of the cabinet. Internal volume is approximately 0.2cuft. I placed a pair of cross braces centered between the drivers going front to back and side to side. You can instead use a window brace if you wish. This cabinet uses the 1-7/8" x 5-5/8" flared port from parts express which results in a tuning of ~65hz. The port is placed on the back and is centered behind the tweeter. Cabinet damping should be light fill or lining of the top half surrounding the port tube but staying behind it's internal opening. I also lined the walls on either side of and behind the woofer. The crossover is placed on the bottom of the cabinet pushed to the back to clear the woofer.
Cabinet Cutlist:
Baffle - 10.5" x 6.5" x 3/4"
Rear - 10.5" x 6.5" x 1/2"
Sides - 10.5" x 7.25" x 1/2"
Top/Bottom/Window Brace - 7.25" x 6.5" x 1/2"
Crossover:
I ended up with a fairly flat and even response which I felt worked and sounded best in this design. There is slight rise at the top octave which could not be pulled down without using another notch filter, however it is not problematic in normal listening.
The waveguide of the RT002A shows excellent horizontal directivity control maintaining near constant directivity down the the crossover where it transitions fairly smoothly to that of the the 5FE120. The woofer response does narrow some in the 2khz range which I believe is due to some diffraction from the cabinet rather then beaming from the driver as the woofer widened back up to match the tweeter at the 3kHz range. Besides that slightly narrowing the horizontal dispersion is roughly 140 degrees (+-70 degrees).
Electrically the lowpass is 3rd order with a RC filter (zobel) acting as a broad contour filter of the upper midrange while the parallel LCR filter placed in series with the driver acts as a notch of the ~950hz peak which had been previously masked in my original measurements. The tweeter also uses a 3rd order filter with a series resistor for a bit padding. The crossover point land right around 3kHz which takes some strain off the ribbon and actually results in a smoother directivity transition between the drivers then the lower crossover point I had originally started with.
The two highpass capacitors (C1/C2) are designed to be polypropylene while the remaining capacitors on the lowpass (C3/C4/C5) are designed to be non polarized polypropylene to save space.
All the inductors are designed to be air cores, L1 and L3 should be 20 gauge while L2 and L4 should be 18 gauge.
The R1 and R2 resistors can be standard 10w wire wound, R3 should be 5 watt if using the optional PCB but can be 10w if building the crossover yourself.
Finally got around to finishing this one up. Much of what has been said about the TM applies to this design as well.
The main difference is obviously the second woofer which is run in parallel, this makes the nominal impedance for the MTM 4 Ohms. The second woofer brings distortion down in the bass and midrange compared to the TM but the ribbon tweeter is still the main weak point when it comes to overall distortion. Although like I had said before most the harmonics are pretty high in the treble frequency so it doesn't sound too bad even though the distortion numbers look poor on paper.
Since the tweeter is rotatable this design could be used as a horizontal center channel though ideally you would want to stay within +- 10 degrees, beyond that you get the normal cancellation/lobbing from the woofers which can be seen in the vertical off axis graphs/polar.
I measured full space sensitivity at ~88.5dB/2.83v/1m or 85.5dB/1w/1m.
Parts List:
Port Tube: 2-1/2" x 8-1/2" (260-478)
Crossover Parts:
Parts can be substituted with others of matching value.
Note - woofer inductors should be at least 18 gauge, tweeter should be 20 gauge.
C1 - 18uF - C2 - 4.0uF - C3 - 8.2uF - C4 - 33uF - C5 - 0.68uF - C6 - 1.0uF
L1 - 1.1mH - L2 - 0.4mH - L3 - 0.1mH - L4 - 0.15mH
R1 - 4 Ohm - R2 - 10 Ohm - R3 - 10 Ohm - R4 - 3 Ohm
The crossover is slightly lower on this MTM version. Because of the lower crossover I could not get the same general shape from the highpass as the MT version and thus needed to add a notch to help tame the peak near 15kHz. The lowpass is also a slightly different configuration, no notch filter but instead a tank filter across the primary coil.